90 Years Strong: Why Banking Local Still Matters

In a financial world that’s increasingly digital, fast-moving, and impersonal, one thing has never gone out of style: people helping people.

That simple idea is what sparked the creation of credit unions nearly a century ago, and it’s the same principle that continues to guide First Financial as we prepare to celebrate 90 years of service today on February 6th!

Pictured above: Tellers and members from our first branch location in Asbury Park, NJ when we were Monmouth County Teachers FCU.

Where Credit Unions Began

Credit unions were born out of necessity. In the early 20th century, many working families and small business owners were shut out of traditional banking. Loans were hard to access, savings options were limited, and financial support often depended on who you knew, not what you needed. Credit unions changed that.

Built by communities, for communities – credit unions were designed to be member-owned, not profit driven. Their mission was clear – to provide fair, affordable financial services and help people build stability, security, and opportunity. That mission still matters today.

The Power of People First Banking

While technology has transformed the way we bank, the value of local, relationship-based financial institutions has only grown stronger.

At First Financial, “putting people first” isn’t just a phrase or a tagline, it’s how business gets done every day. When you become a member, that means you’ll receive:

  • Personal service from people who know your name, your financial goals, and your community.
  • Thoughtful lending decisions made locally, not by algorithms or distant headquarters.
  • Financial guidance rooted in trust, not just transactions.

When you walk into our credit union or connect with us online, you’re not just an account number: You’re a member. An owner. A neighbor.

Investing Where It Matters Most

Local banking keeps dollars circulating close to home. Credit unions are known to reinvest in the communities they serve – supporting local businesses, non-profits, schools, and families. Every loan, every account, and every financial decision contributes to a stronger local economy.

Over the past 90 years, First Financial has grown alongside the people and communities it serves, adapting to changing needs while staying rooted in the same cooperative values that sparked its founding.

Trust Built Over Generations

For nine decades, members have turned to First Financial during life’s biggest moments – buying a home, starting a business, planning their future, and navigating unexpected challenges. Those relationships span generations, creating a legacy of stability and care that larger institutions typically can’t replicate. In an era when financial choices can feel overwhelming, having a trusted local partner makes all the difference.

Honoring the Past, Building the Future

As we celebrate our official 90th anniversary, we’re taking time to reflect on where we’ve been and where we’re going.

This milestone isn’t just about longevity. It’s about resilience, adaptability, and staying true to the values that matter most. Throughout the year ahead, we’ll be celebrating this anniversary with member stories, special promotions, and moments that honor our history while looking toward the future. You can find out all the ways we’ll be celebrating 90 years on our website, which will continuously be updated throughout 2026.

Why Banking Local Still Matters

Ninety years strong is more than a milestone, it’s a reminder that when financial institutions are built on trust, service, and community – everyone benefits. Local decisions create lasting impact, and when people come together with a shared purpose – they can build something that lasts for generations.

Thank you for being part of our story. Here’s to 90 years, and many more to come!

Want to learn more about our journey? Explore our history and the people-first values that have guided us for 90 years.

Not a First Financial member yet but want to join us? First Financial membership is open to anyone who lives, works, worships, volunteers, or attends school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in New Jersey. Learn more about getting started on our website, or stop into any of our branch locations.

*A First Financial membership is available to anyone who lives, works, worships, volunteers or attends school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties.  A $5 deposit in a base savings account is required for credit union membership prior to opening any other account. All personal memberships are part of the Rewards First program and a $5 per month non-participation fee is charged to the base savings account for memberships not meeting the minimum requirements of the program. Click here to view full Rewards First program details. Some restrictions apply, contact the Credit Union for more information.

First Financial Member Spotlight: Michael Balsamo

For more than 20 years, Michael Balsamo has trusted First Financial as his banking partner. As a seasoned realtor with a deep commitment to his clients, Michael values the personalized service and support he experiences every time he walks into a First Financial branch. “Whenever I walk into a branch, everybody says hello and makes me feel like a member of their family,” he shares. With a special appreciation for the Toms River branch, Michael often works closely with Branch Manager Brian Lang and his team, who he says consistently provide “top-notch” service.

As a full-time real estate agent with REMAX Revolution, Michael’s clients depend on him to recommend reliable mortgage solutions, and First Financial is at the top of his list. In addition to mortgage services, Michael finds First Financial’s online banking tools essential for managing his day-to-day transactions. “I pay my bills online, and if I ever have a question, their 800-number support is always helpful,” he says. First Financial’s blend of convenience and reliability allows him to bank wherever and whenever he needs to, making it easy to stay on top of his finances.

Reflecting on his long-standing relationship with First Financial – Michael confidently shares, “I would never think of banking with anyone else. It’s been over 20 years, and I’m never going to leave.”

We’re honored to be part of Michael’s financial journey and are committed to providing him with exceptional service. Be sure to check out his video interview below.

How to Join First Financial

If you live, work, worship, volunteer, or attend school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in NJ, you’re eligible to become a First Financial member. Businesses in Monmouth or Ocean Counties and our community partners are also eligible for membership. To join, simply open a savings account with $5 — it’s that easy! Once you’re a member, your immediate family can also sign up. To get started, call us at 732.312.1500, email info@firstffcu.com, or stop by any of our local branches.

First Financial Member Spotlight: Lorna Cooper-Piver

“All through the years I’ve been coming, all 47 years – First Financial has been a solid place to bank.”

Since March of 1976, First Financial has had the privilege of being part of Lorna Cooper-Piver’s financial journey. Lorna’s story is not just one of long-standing membership, but also a testament to the unwavering trust and support she has found in banking with us.

Lorna’s connection with First Financial began while she was still a high school senior. Encouraged by her father, she opened a savings account. It was a step toward building a secure financial future, and little did she know – it would mark the beginning of a decades-long relationship.

Toward the beginning of her membership, Lorna applied for a car loan that was quick and simple to attain. This showcased our commitment to providing opportunities for our members, even those just starting out in their financial journey.

Lorna’s story is a reminder of the enduring relationships we build with our members. We’re not just a financial institution – we’re a partner in your financial well-being, offering reliability and support through every stage of life.

Check out our video interview with Lorna and learn more about her remarkable journey as a long-time First Financial member.

How to join First Financial

If you live, work, worship, volunteer, or attend school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in NJ, you’re eligible to become a member. Businesses in Monmouth or Ocean Counties and our community partners are also eligible for membership. To join, all you have to do is open a savings account with $5. It’s that easy! Once you’re a member, your immediate family can also sign up. To get started, call us at 732.312.1500, email info@firstffcu.com, or stop by any of our local branches.

First Financial Member Spotlight: Brian Jackson

“If you’re looking for a bank where you can feel at home, choose First Financial.”

Welcome back to our First Financial member spotlight – a series featuring some of our valued credit union members who have happily worked with us over the years. Next up is our long-time member, Brian Jackson.

Brian has been banking with us for over 35 years. He was even a member back when we were known as Mon-Oc Teachers Federal Credit Union, 28 years ago! Brian takes full advantage of our membership benefits and has a savings and checking account with us.

Watch the video to learn how we exceeded Brian’s expectations throughout the pandemic and as he works toward retirement!

How to join First Financial

If you live, work, worship, volunteer, or attend school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in NJ, you’re eligible to become a member. Businesses in Monmouth or Ocean Counties and our community partners are also eligible for membership. To join, all you have to do is open a savings account with $5. It’s that easy! Once you’re a member, your immediate family can also sign up. To get started, call us at 732.312.1500, email info@firstffcu.com, or stop by any of our local branches.

First Financial Business Member Spotlight: Papa John’s

“First Financial is always there for our financial needs as busy business owners.”

As 2022 comes to a close, we’re reflecting on all the supportive individuals we’ve had the privilege to work with this year – including our business members. We’re so grateful to help businesses in our community thrive and are excited for even more growth in the years ahead.

With that said, we’re happy to share our next First Financial member spotlight – a series where we feature some of our personal and business credit union members. This time we’re highlighting Ayesha and Syed Nawazuddin, owners of Papa John’s in Neptune and West Long Branch, NJ.

Ayesha and Syed joined First Financial in 2019 after receiving better care than they previously had at other larger banks. Since then, they’ve opened a business checking and savings account, an auto loan, and they even added personal accounts. “We feel like a close family, and they are always there for our financial needs,” Ayesha shared.

Learn more about their experience banking with First Financial in the video below.

If you’re looking to grab a slice of their iconic “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza” pies, be sure to visit one of Ayesha and Syed’s locations:

Papa John’s of Neptune

712 Rt. 35 | (732) 898-6868

Papa John’s of West Long Branch

357 Monmouth Rd. | (732) 229-0200

How to join First Financial

If you live, work, worship, volunteer, or attend school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in NJ, you’re eligible to become a member. Businesses in Monmouth or Ocean Counties and our community partners are also eligible for membership. To join, all you have to do is open a savings account with $5. It’s that easy! Once you’re a member, your immediate family can also sign up. To get started, call us at 732.312.1500, email info@firstffcu.com, or stop by any of our local branches.

First Financial Business Member Spotlight: Hairstylist for the Nations

“I have many ideas about my business and First Financial knows how to help.”

It’s Small Business Saturday, and we are taking the opportunity to highlight one of our wonderful business members to encourage the support of shopping and using local Monmouth & Ocean County small businesses! With that being said, welcome back to our First Financial member spotlight – a series where we feature some of our personal and business credit union members who we’ve happily worked with over the years. This time we’re shining a light on business member Ameerah Jones, the owner of Hairstylist for the Nations in Shrewsbury, NJ.

Ameerah started Hairstylist for the Nations in 2012 after working in the fashion industry. One of the first reasons she decided to bank with First Financial was because there were no monthly fees for business checking accounts. Over time, Ameerah learned that First Financial met her needs as a freelance business owner in a fast-paced environment where she is constantly on the go – especially with her business’ credit card processing. The credit union also continues to be invested in helping her business grow.

Learn more about her experience in banking with First Financial in the video below, and why Ameerah recommends our business banking to other business owners she knows.

If you’re looking to book your next hair appointment, check out Hairstylist for the Nations located at 1026 Broad Street, Suite 6 in Shrewsbury. You can also call 732.242.7733.

How to join First Financial

If you live, work, worship, volunteer, or attend school in Monmouth or Ocean Counties in NJ, you’re eligible to become a member. Businesses in Monmouth or Ocean Counties and our community partners are also eligible for membership. To join, all you have to do is open a savings account with $5. It’s that easy! Once you’re a member, your immediate family can also sign up. To get started, call us at 732.312.1500, email info@firstffcu.com, or stop by any of our local branches.